Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

PCLinuxOS and Ubuntu - communities divided

Filed under
PCLOS
Ubuntu

I never imagined that Linux communities could be quite so secular, yet I have been proven wrong over the past couple of days. What started with a slightly skewed review on ThePCSpy.com turned into a small distro war and it looks to have continued into the comments on my review of PCLinuxOS 2007. What's going on?

Oli from ThePCSpy wrote a review on PCLOS2007 where he proclaimed a strong distaste for the Draklive installer, arguing that Ubuntu's partition manager (Gparted) was a superior implementation. Many read his review as a means of promoting Ubuntu by pulling PCLOS down and that certainly wasn't his intention - but let's not get into that now.

I stated in my review that I was deeply concerned by the actions of the PCLOS community and while I was very impressed with the release itself, the childish actions of *some* community members soured the taste a little bit. This spread over into my review where discussion remained off topic and most users felt the need to comment on the situation rather than my review. I can't help but wonder what's going on?

Full Story.



Re: PCLinuxOS and Ubuntu Communities Divided

Each distro has its own passionate devotees. As a PCLinuxOS user, I have said that Ubuntu is overrated, and I don't understand why it's so popular. But it is, and I welcome any convert from MS Win to Ubuntu (or any other version of GNU/Linux).

That's about it, for me . . . no real bashing. Maybe a little smoke, but no real fire of discord blazing. I suspect I'm typical in these respects.

No division

There is no division just some blogger trying to twist things around and get people upset.

MCN Live

I think MCNLive is much better than PC Linux OS and Ubuntu,

More people need to take a good look at MCNLive personally I think it's strides better then PCLOS

Ubuntu is a great Operating System when in coparision to windows , but when compared to mandriva based distros it seems to fall a bit short , perhaps this is just me though

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

More in Tux Machines

GNOME 3.26 Desktop Environment to Offer Todoist Integration, Quarter Tiling

They came much faster than we expected, and it looks like more features of the upcoming GNOME 3.26 desktop environment for GNU/Linux distribution have been revealed. Read more

Project Halium Seeks A Unified Mobile GNU/Linux

New forks of GNU/Linux come out all the time, but some, like the newly unveiled Project Halium, actively seek to unite a given landscape. In this case the mobile world. Rather than being yet another version of Linux on mobile devices, like SailfishOS or Ubuntu Touch, Project Halium’s goal is to create a base that anybody can work off of to integrate all sorts of Linux code into the Android stack smoothly. Ideally, Project Halium wants to not only build out a base framework that anybody can use to hook their Linux project into Android’s soft underbelly of code and run it on an Android device, but they want to be the de facto example of such, in much the same way that saying the word “Linux” out in public will make many people immediately think of Ubuntu. Read more

3 Linux questions from the community

In the last The Queue, I flipped the script and asked you questions as opposed to answering them. It was so well received, I'm going to keep it going with three more questions this month. I'll resume answering next month, so don't forget you can fill the queue with your questions about Linux, building and maintaining communities, contributing to an open source project, and anything else you'd like to know. While the previous two questions were a bit philosophical, this month we'll keep it fun. Read more

Flatpak 0.9.3 Linux App Sandboxing Framework Released with Many Builder Changes

Alex Larsson from the Flatpak team announces the release and immediate availability of the third maintenance update to the Flatpak 0.9 series of the open-source Linux application sandboxing and distribution framework. Read more