KDE4: The MS Vista of Linux?
Most people in Linux circles have heard the slogan: "Release Early, Release Often." This often translates to a rule that you make small software changes frequently instead of doing major overhauls that take a long time to get out the door. Many of the most successful open source projects abide by this rule. Examples include the Linux Kernel itself, the top community based Linux distributions and Gnome. These projects, for the most part, are very successful.
Two other projects, recently, have strayed from the above rule and are experiencing similar fates: Microsoft Vista and KDE4. Here are 5 interesting parallels:
1. Both took too long to get out the door. Vista disappointed many with how long it took to finally be released. People were similarly disappointed with KDE4. For example, Ubuntu users hoped to see KDE4 in Gutsy, but then it was delayed. Next they hoped to see it it in Hardy LTS. Again, between delays plus the fact it was so disappointing, there is no Hardy LTS with KDE4. Contrast this with the "release early, release often" Gnome which is always releases on time, and is always stable enough when released to build a distro off of in in a month or two.
2. Once out the door both were disappointments.


Broken Link...
Oops. Seems like the author retracted it. It's not in the front page, either.
pity
I guess he got a lot of flak and didnt have the integrity to stand up for his convictions. Pity really because a lot of us agree with him.
why are people so 'gun ho' to shoot down KDE4?
Sorry to say but without going into the details I believe that KDE4 is going to approach a point where everyone will like it more.
I am getting annoyed when people start kicking off over a part of KDE4 being 'broken' or not offering what they want, mainly when the reason for moving away from the old app was either it was a garbled hunk of code or nobody wanted to take responsibility for it.
A lot of KDE core developers moved away from it yes but thats the wonder of opensource, just run with KDE3 and modify it yourself or go with an alternative
I'm sure I would like to see KDE 3.6 if enough people decide to develop on it but I personally am thankful that KDE basically sat down and asked how can we make this all better and started developing according to an open 'master plan'.
And lets face it Gnome 3.0, if or when it happens will get shot down as either not having enough feature changes to warrant getting the 3 revision or it will also be as unstable as KDE4 (or will sit in rc limbo for a few months first).
Sorry guys not looking to flame but starting to get a bit cheesed off with the KDE4 rants, but surely if you don't like it, don't use it!
The He-Man KDE4 Hater's Club
Like all red blooded sexually potent male Linux Geeks, I too hate KDE 4, but KDE 3 is not going anywhere, so there's no need to panic, and there's no reason for anyone to lose sight of the mutual respect needed to foster a community.
I think we owe a debt of gratitude to Aaron and to SJVN for being the respective lightning rods for the recent airing of anxieties. I can't imagine what it would be like to be demonized in the GNU/Linux online community as both these men have been. Aaron was helpful and as patient as could be expected, taking the time to answer individual users concerns when he had enough on his plate. He personally helped me understand the situation and to calm the hell down more than any one person. SJVN is often misunderstood, in my opinion. People think he's trying to manipulate hits, but so many others have resorted to cheap tricks without having anything interesting to say. It's easy to generate hits with a provocative headline, but SJVN seems to have a gift for provocative ideas, ideas that generate discussion as well as page hits. As far as I can know, neither of these men behaved dishonorably at any time, and we are lucky to have both of them.
I think what happened was that many people suddenly realized that their misgivings about KDE4 were not theirs alone, and a great communal outpouring of emotion followed... and of course, that touched off conflict in turn. It was bound to happen, the sooner the better.
Honestly, I haven't a clue how I'm going to feel about KDE4 a year from now. Let's just wait and see, because that's what needs to be done. Now that cooler heads seem to be carrying the day. I doubt that anyone seriously expects KDE to take a U-turn before KDE 4 is fully deployed. I don't anticipate that a fork will be required, but if it is, we'll talk about it then. I'm glad it's all out in the open, and I thank the vast majority of the community for not resorting to the disrespect for others that a minority resorted to.
re: He-Man KDE4 Hater's Club
Like all red blooded sexually potent male Linux Geeks, I too hate KDE 4
I personally hated it at first too, but I'm starting to come around I think.
re: re: He-Man KDE4 Hater's Club
I've installed Sidux on my trial machine, and added the Debian "experimental" repository wherein KDE 4.1 rc1 lies. So, I've been playing with KDE 4.1 rc1, as an installed desktop, for a couple of days.
I'll not say much before 4.1 final comes out...but after some initial awkwardness, I'm liking it more as I use it.
Leave KDE4 Alone!!1111111111
KDE 4.1 release plan
OK, find the KDE 4.1 release plan from the KDE techbase site below. Clearly, it's still a work in progress. Will we like it? Hate it? Tolerate it until KDE 4.2? Stay with KDE 3.5.x? The jury's still out. It's still too early to really tell and many people suffer from premature etrashculation.
Contents
* 1 KDE 4.1
o 1.1 April 20th, 2008: Soft Feature Freeze
o 1.2 April 22nd, 2008: Tag KDE 4.1 Alpha 1
o 1.3 April 29th, 2008: Release KDE 4.1 Alpha 1
o 1.4 May 19th, 2008: Hard Feature Freeze
o 1.5 May 20th, 2008: Message Freeze.
o 1.6 May 20th, 2008: Tag KDE 4.1 Beta 1
o 1.7 May 27th, 2008: Release KDE 4.1 Beta 1
o 1.8 June 3rd, 2008: Documentation/Handbook Freeze
o 1.9 June 17th, 2008: Tag KDE 4.1 Beta 2
o 1.10 June 24th, 2008: Release KDE 4.1 Beta 2
o 1.11 July 8th, 2008: Artwork and Bindings Freeze
o 1.12 July 8th, 2008: Tag KDE 4.1 RC 1
o 1.13 July 15th, 2008: Release KDE 4.1 RC 1
o 1.14 July 22nd, 2008: Tag KDE 4.1
o 1.15 July 29th, 2008: Release KDE 4.1