Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

google is your butler- the tension between utility and privacy

Filed under

I’ve often defended Google’s thirst to know things about people with a butler analogy. Good software should, like a butler, try hard to understand your preferences and act on them for you without you even realizing they are there. That means learning and remembering things you’ve done in the past, and using that to base recommendations on.

Like a butler, you want your tools to work intelligently based on context and history, and Google is without doubt one of those tools- for many of us, the most important single tool in our computing lives. The problem, of course, is that your butler has a lot of incentives to keep your private information private.

Google’s incentives run at least partially the other way- they have strong incentives to mine that data extensively, to share it with others, and to collect well more than most people might think is useful, in the name of being the ultimate butler. And these incentives lead to risks- incentives to share with third parties that you might not trust; risks that things might be subpoenaed; risks that they might leak to Google employees or even outside Google; risks that effective advertising might use such information to manipulate your political views. On balance, most of us are going to look at these issues and decide that we’re OK with Google knowing these things, because the risks are remote and the benefits tangible. So we acknowledge there is a tension between privacy and functionality, and move on.

Rest Here

More in Tux Machines

Announcing GitTorrent: A Decentralized GitHub

I’ve been working on building a decentralized GitHub, and I’d like to talk about what this means and why it matters — and more importantly, show you how it can be done and real GitTorrent code I’ve implemented so far. Read more Also: Why aren't you using github?

Wine Announcement

The Wine development release 1.7.44 is now available. What's new in this release (see below for details): - More support for the COM interfaces of the RichEdit control. - Initial version of a SmartTee filter. - Some more support for the ARM64 platform. - Support for the null device kernel object. - Various bug fixes. Read more

Richard Stallman and Phil Zimmerman underline key concerns with tech sector

Two of technology's most pioneering developers have strongly criticised the current state of the industry, warning that the right to encryption is doomed and that users are exploited by the software that they use. Open sourcerer Richard Stallman has painted a very bleak picture of today's technology and communications environment, describing proprietary software as "malware". Stallman, the founder of the free software movement, perhaps not surprisingly has a very jaundiced view of proprietary software, and of Microsoft Windows especially. Read more

GNOME 3.17.2

here is the second snapshot of the GNOME 3.17 development cycle, the 3.17.2 release. Don't miss the Bastien blog post about some cool stuff new on this release [1] To build GNOME 3.17.2, you can use the jhbuild [1] modulesets [2] (which use the exact tarball versions from the official release). [1] [2] [3] Read more