Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

The Great Fallacy of BSD Unix vs. Linux

Filed under
Linux
BSD

"Linux is just a kernel." It's a commonly heard refrain amongst the arguments put forward by BSD Unix aficionados, and it is a true statement, but it is all too often abused to try to make a fallacious point.


FreeBSD, NetBSD, and OpenBSD are complete core operating system projects. Each of these projects has integral to it the concept of a "base system", which consists of the kernel, basic userland, et cetera. The Linux project itself is only the kernel, by contrast; to make a complete operating system, you need to add a bunch of stuff from outside the Linux project. Many people and organizations have done so, resulting in a plethora of what are known as "Linux distributions". These distributions, or "distros", of Linux vary significantly from one case to the next.

A typical BSD-oriented list of differences between a BSD Unix OS and Linux will point out that "Linux is just a kernel," with a wide variety of distributions being built on top of it, then go on to explain how (to quote the FreeBSD and Linux post at RootBSD):

Rest Here




More in Tux Machines

The Ubuntu Phone That Transforms into a PC Will Be Built by BQ

Canonical is still quite eager to have a "convergence" device out into the wild and it looks that BQ will be the company to build it. Read more

SourceForge commits reputational suicide

Despite seeming reformed last year, SourceForge has been caught red-handed abusing the reputations of open source projects Read more

Nintendo Nixes Android Rumors

  • Nintendo Nixes Android Rumors
  • 3 Reasons Nintendo Should Switch to Google Android
    What are the odds Nintendo’s next platform, possibly a suite of devices codenamed “NX,” would emerge running a flavor of Google’s popular operating system, as claimed by a single anonymous insider in a column by Japanese biz paper Nikkei?
  • Nintendo's next console won't run Android after all
    Aside from its codename, we know little about Nintendo's in-development "NX" console. Yesterday, however, Japanese publication Nikkei claimed to have hit upon a particularly juicy detail about the next-gen gaming system, with its sources stating the NX will run some form of Google's Android OS. The rumor wasn't exactly far-fetched, given Nintendo's plans to get into mobile games this year; but alas, it appears to have been a blast of hot air.

First Open Automotive Grade Linux Spec Released

Since its inception, the Linux Foundation's Automotive Grade Linux project has promoted itself as a collaborative open source project. With the release of the first AGL Requirements Specification for Linux-based in-vehicle infotainment (IVI), AGL has earned that description more than ever. Read more