Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

The 'Mandriva Wars' and More

Filed under

The Cyber Cynic podcast with Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols looks at the popular French-based Linux distributor Mandriva and its troubles in eWEEK Podcast #47.

Linux Watch Editor Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols looks at a number of issues this week, including the "Mandriva Wars."

It's sad that the popular French-based Linux distributor has errupted into infighting with its community and one of its founders, Gael Duval, fighting with the company over his firing. Unfortunately, it's just the way of businesses as they grow from being technology-first companies to being business-first companies.

eWEEK Podcast #47.

Mandriva Wars

I don't know that I would call it a "war" exactly, but many in the Mandriva Club (myself included) believe that this is a clear sign that club members won't count for much from now on.

Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols podcast describes the situation very clearly.

I have 9 months left to go before my club membership expires. It's becoming more doubtful by the day that I will renew that membership. In fact, when it expires, I'll likely start sending that money to PCLinuxOS.

That's because I just switched my *main* machine over to PCLinuxOS this weekend (Since PCLinuxOS was originally a fork of Mandrake 9.2, it's admittedly not much of a stretch. The best thing about it is I now have so little tinkering to do to get things "just right"--Tex and the PCLinuxOS gang use really sensible preset configuration defaults).

Like many, I first found when Tex was building KDE RPM's for Mandrake Linux years ago. I had done a google search for Mandrake RPMs, and there was Tex kept pumping out these incredible KDE RPMs and kept us all up to date--and they were so much better than Mandrake's official KDE RPMs.

As an aside, I also tried Kubuntu--installed it on my laptop a couple of days ago. I'm not tremendously impressed--and I don't quite understand Ubuntu/Kubuntu's enormous popularity. Oh well, each to thine own.

Back to Mandriva. Mandriva's 2006 release was buggy. It came out just after KDE 3.5.0 was released, and had KDE 3.4.x. In all that time, Mandriva never has released a 3.5.x KDE version for version 2006. Nada. No KDE upgrade. This just doesn't make it.

I wish Mandriva well. But they'll have to do some incredible work to get my $$$ again (and yes, I have sent some money to PCLinuxOS).

Gary Frankenbery

RE: Mandriva Wars


Sorry for speaking about GNOME -- I don't use KDE, except when I'm forced to.

1. Does the Club membership provided you with the XMas edition of MDK 2006? Was it better than the official, purchasable one? (Not being a member, I can't tell.)
At least, the XMas special edition should have GNOME 2.12.

2. Being it unofficial, but is KDE 3.5 from working?

3. The fame of Kubuntu is totally unjustified! It's just a KDE clone of Ubuntu, but I can't see what shines in it either.
The "original" Ubuntu however benefits from the fact 4.10 Warty actually was a good working GNOME 2.8 incarnation. And 5.04 Hoary was quite a good GNOME 2.10 too. After that and besides that... I guess Ubuntu got spread because of the people liking to receive free CDs by post! (I can't explain the hype if not this way out.)

RE: Re: Mandriva Wars

AFAIK the Christmas Club Edition of Mandriva available to Mandriva club members was the same as official purchasable (Powerpack) version. Anyway, the Christmas Club edition came with Gnome 2.10. This has not been updated.

Glad to hear that others share my opinion on Ubuntu/Kubuntu--it's ok, but nothing special.

I did not try to install seerofsouls (hawkwind's) KDE 3.5.1 RPMs on my Mandriva box. Some have had success with it, others haven't. Those KDE RPM's are backported from the Mandriva Cooker (development version) to Mandriva 2006. I would say that one would need to read their howto very carefully, and follow it to the letter.

The more I use PCLinuxOS on my home system, the more I'm glad I made the transition. PCLinuxOS has its faults, but its running great for me.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

More in Tux Machines

Wine Staging: Release 1.7.52

Some minutes ago we released Wine Staging 1.7.52. This is the first release after WineConf 2015 and the integration into WineHQ. Some of the changes related to the integration have been realized in the meantime and you should now use the WineHQ bug tracker for reporting bugs. Just open them as regular Wine bugs and mention the used wine version. Although this news is mostly about the source code changes, I would like to mention that Arch Linux now provides an official package which is also named wine-staging and therefore conflicts with our packages. The package installs into /usr instead of /opt/wine-staging so you might run into conflicts with other wine versions. Take a look at our Wiki for more information. Read more

today's leftovers

  • A gentle introduction to microservices
    What are microservices? Have you heard the phrase "microservices" used in a discussion of modern application development and wondered what it's all about?
  • There's A Lot Of Exciting AMDGPU DRM Code Brewing For Eventual Catalyst Support
    One of the big items still in the works as part of AMD's unified Linux driver strategy is that the Catalyst proprietary driver will be isolated to user-space and make use of the AMDGPU kernel DRM driver. Being publicly now in development in a few code branches are changes to the AMD DRM code for beginning to suit more of it to Catalyst's driver design.
  • Linux Kernel 4.2.3 Is Out with Open vSwitch and IPv6 Fixes, Updated Networking Drivers
    After only 4 days from the release of the second maintenance version of the Linux 4.2 kernel series, Greg Kroah-Hartman comes today, October 3, with news about the release of Linux kernel 4.2.3.
  • Linux Foundation Says Open Source Code Worth $5 Billion
  • Mesa 10.6.9 Released, Marks The End Of The Line: Upgrade To Mesa 11
    Emil Velikov announced Mesa 10.6.9 today as the newest point release for the aging Mesa 10.6 series. Mesa 10.6.9 fixes an Intel crash issue with KDE, Unreal Tournament is fixed for Gallium3D drivers, and there are various other Mesa OpenGL fixes.
  • GNOME's 2014 Annual Report Published
    For those wondering about the state of GNOME, their annual report is now available. The GNOME Foundation 2014 annual report covers their financial situation, their trademark battle with GroupOn, their temporary financial shortfall due to the OPW project, the hack/developer events engaged in, and much more.
  • KDE Plasma 5.4.2, bugfix Release for October, is already landing in Kubuntu Wily
  • Kubuntu 15.10 Will Have KDE Plasma 5.4.2
    Kubuntu 15.10 "Wily Werewolf" is being released later this month and it will feature the very latest KDE Plasma 5.4 point release. Plasma 5.4.2 isn't being released until next week but the Kubuntu crew is pushing it early into 15.10 Wily now to ensure it arrives with the 15.10 debut.
  • Randa Meetings update
    I am really not a person who blogs much and its bit late, please bare with me in case if anyone does not like the way article is written or how it is formatted. I really feel good being KDE user since 2005. Officially I started coding / contributing to minor stuff in KDE in 2010. Switzerland is an awesome place and I really liked Randa. Speaking of Switzerland, for me those trains are art of engineering. I would like to thank KDE e.v. and other sponsors for making this event happen.
  • KaOS 2015.10 Officially Released with a Gorgeous KDE Plasma 5.4 Desktop, Wayland Session
    On October 2, Anke Boersma had the great pleasure of announcing the release and immediate availability for download of the KaOS 2015.10 GNU/Linux computer operating system.
  • KaOS 2015.10 KDE-focused Linux distro available now
    While I am a GNOME fan, I recognize how wonderful KDE is too. If you prefer a traditional desktop user interface, KDE is a smart choice. Not only is it it easy to use for beginners, but it offers a ton of customization options for advanced users too. There are quite a few KDE-based Linux distros, such as Kubuntu, Linux Mint KDE, and Netrunner, but the lesser known KaOS offers a more pure experience. This distro has a goal of remaining lean, while being fairly bleeding edge regarding KDE packages -- it is a great showcase for the desktop environment. Today, version 2015.10 sees release, and you can download it now.
  • Network Security Toolkit 22-7248 Screenshot Tour
  • SparkyLinux 4.1 KDE Screenshot Tour
  • Gentoo-Based Calculate Linux 15 Released
    Calculate Linux 15 was released today in its KDE, MATE, and Xfce desktop spins along with Calculate Linux Directory Server, Linux Scratch, Scratch Server, and Media Center editions.
  • Ubuntu To Make It Easier To Ship Micro-Release Updates, New Features Post-LTS
    Generally Ubuntu Linux hasn't allowed new minor point releases of software to be sent down as stable release updates (SRUs) once the Ubuntu release ships, but there's been many exceptions, and now Ubuntu's Technical Board has agreed to make changes to make it easier to send down micro-release updates as well as offering new features to existing LTS (Long-Term Support) releases.

Manjaro 15.09 (Bellatrix) Update With Calamares Installer, Tweaks And Latest Applications

Manjaro Linux Bellatrix 15.09 released

Manjaro Linux 15.09, codenamed Bellatrix has been released with some tweaks into the graphical and terminal installer. The release makes it easier to install Manjaro on your system. Also the latest apps have been included in the Bellatrix. The Manjaro is easy to use Linux distribution, so give it a try from 15.09 with easy to install graphical interface.

Read At LinuxAndUbuntu