Language Selection

English French German Italian Portuguese Spanish

The 'Mandriva Wars' and More

Filed under
MDV

The Cyber Cynic podcast with Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols looks at the popular French-based Linux distributor Mandriva and its troubles in eWEEK Podcast #47.

Linux Watch Editor Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols looks at a number of issues this week, including the "Mandriva Wars."

It's sad that the popular French-based Linux distributor has errupted into infighting with its community and one of its founders, Gael Duval, fighting with the company over his firing. Unfortunately, it's just the way of businesses as they grow from being technology-first companies to being business-first companies.

eWEEK Podcast #47.

Mandriva Wars

I don't know that I would call it a "war" exactly, but many in the Mandriva Club (myself included) believe that this is a clear sign that club members won't count for much from now on.

Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols podcast describes the situation very clearly.

I have 9 months left to go before my club membership expires. It's becoming more doubtful by the day that I will renew that membership. In fact, when it expires, I'll likely start sending that money to PCLinuxOS.

That's because I just switched my *main* machine over to PCLinuxOS this weekend (Since PCLinuxOS was originally a fork of Mandrake 9.2, it's admittedly not much of a stretch. The best thing about it is I now have so little tinkering to do to get things "just right"--Tex and the PCLinuxOS gang use really sensible preset configuration defaults).

Like many, I first found pclinuxonline.com when Tex was building KDE RPM's for Mandrake Linux years ago. I had done a google search for Mandrake RPMs, and there was pclinuxonline.com. Tex kept pumping out these incredible KDE RPMs and kept us all up to date--and they were so much better than Mandrake's official KDE RPMs.

As an aside, I also tried Kubuntu--installed it on my laptop a couple of days ago. I'm not tremendously impressed--and I don't quite understand Ubuntu/Kubuntu's enormous popularity. Oh well, each to thine own.

Back to Mandriva. Mandriva's 2006 release was buggy. It came out just after KDE 3.5.0 was released, and had KDE 3.4.x. In all that time, Mandriva never has released a 3.5.x KDE version for version 2006. Nada. No KDE upgrade. This just doesn't make it.

I wish Mandriva well. But they'll have to do some incredible work to get my $$$ again (and yes, I have sent some money to PCLinuxOS).

Gary Frankenbery

RE: Mandriva Wars

Gary,

Sorry for speaking about GNOME -- I don't use KDE, except when I'm forced to.

1. Does the Club membership provided you with the XMas edition of MDK 2006? Was it better than the official, purchasable one? (Not being a member, I can't tell.)
At least, the XMas special edition should have GNOME 2.12.

2. Being it unofficial, but is KDE 3.5 from http://seerofsouls.com/mandriva/2006/i586/ working?

3. The fame of Kubuntu is totally unjustified! It's just a KDE clone of Ubuntu, but I can't see what shines in it either.
The "original" Ubuntu however benefits from the fact 4.10 Warty actually was a good working GNOME 2.8 incarnation. And 5.04 Hoary was quite a good GNOME 2.10 too. After that and besides that... I guess Ubuntu got spread because of the people liking to receive free CDs by post! (I can't explain the hype if not this way out.)

RE: Re: Mandriva Wars

AFAIK the Christmas Club Edition of Mandriva available to Mandriva club members was the same as official purchasable (Powerpack) version. Anyway, the Christmas Club edition came with Gnome 2.10. This has not been updated.

Glad to hear that others share my opinion on Ubuntu/Kubuntu--it's ok, but nothing special.

I did not try to install seerofsouls (hawkwind's) KDE 3.5.1 RPMs on my Mandriva box. Some have had success with it, others haven't. Those KDE RPM's are backported from the Mandriva Cooker (development version) to Mandriva 2006. I would say that one would need to read their howto very carefully, and follow it to the letter.

The more I use PCLinuxOS on my home system, the more I'm glad I made the transition. PCLinuxOS has its faults, but its running great for me.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

More in Tux Machines

Android Leftovers

Report from Debian SnowCamp and a Look at Solyd XK, a Debian-Based Distribution

  • Report from Debian SnowCamp: day 1
  • Report from Debian SnowCamp: day 2
    Of course, we’re still sorely lacking volunteers who would really care about mentors.debian.net; the codebase is a pile of hacks upon hacks upon hacks, all relying on an old version of a deprecated Python web framework. A few attempts have been made at a smooth transition to a more recent framework, without really panning out, mostly for lack of time on the part of the people running the service. I’m still convinced things should restart from scratch, but I don’t currently have the energy or time to drive it… Ugh.
  • Installing Solyd XK, a Debian based Linux distribution : Cooking With Linux
    It's time for some more "Cooking With Linux" without a net, meaning the video you are about to watch was recorded live. Today, I'm going to install a new Linux distribution (new to me, anyhow) called Solyd XK.

Aquaris E4.5 Ubuntu Phone - With Android

I ever so slightly regret the "upgrade" to Android. With a version less than the tablet, the UI changes are extremely noticeable, and the transition isn't as smooth. The device lags, and it just doesn't have enough processing power to give the necessary feel of goodness and elegance. On the other hand, you get tons of native applications that you can actually use, as opposed to the Ubuntu Touch idea. Shame really. For 'tis a compromise. If you ask me, I wholeheartedly embrace the M10 tablet upgrade, but on the phone, you might as well keep Ubuntu unless you need the device for serious use. If it's just an opportunistic call/SMS thing for when abroad and such, or to loan to friends, the original combo is adequate. If you need apps, then Android is the way to go, but do not except any miracles. It won't be speedy, and it won't be too pretty. All in all, an okay player. It is silly attaching sentiments to software or hardware, but I do guess I will fondly remember the Ubuntu phone attempt as a noble idea to make something great and fun. I could have kept the device in its original state, perhaps, but in the end, it would have ended in a pile of ancient stuff you keep around for a decade until you decide you need to throw it away to leave room for fresh memories and less ancient stuff. Having a flawless Android experience would have helped soften the edge, but as it is, it remains the bittersweet attempt at what could have been a revolution. The end. Read more Also: Ubuntu Desktop weekly update – February 23, 2018

​Docker and Red Hat News

  • ​Docker has a business plan headache
    We love containers. And, for most of us, containers means Docker. As RightScale observed in its RightScale 2018 State of the Cloud report, Docker's adoption by the industry has increased to 49 percent from 35 percent in 2017.
  • Mycroft Widget, Atos and Red Hat's New Cloud Container Solution, npm Bug and More
    Atos and Red Hat announced this morning "a new fully-managed cloud container solution - Atos Managed OpenShift (AMOS) - built on Red Hat OpenShift Container Platform". The press release adds, "Because AMOS is built on Red Hat OpenShift Container Platform, a container-centric hybrid cloud solution, it can deliver the flexibility customers seek from cloud-native and container-based applications."
  • Red Hat Decision Manager 7 Boosts BPM with Low-Code Approach
    Red Hat is perhaps best known for its Enterprise Linux platform, but it has been a player in the Business Process Management (BPM) suite for over a decade too. On Feb. 21, Red Hat Decision Manager 7 was officially announced as the successor to the company's JBoss Business Rules Management System (BRMS) product. Red Hat first released BRMS back in May 2009 which itself was an evolution of the JBoss Rules Engine.
  • Red Hat, Inc. (NYSE:RHT) – Active Stock Evaluation